Maybe your tree fell during a storm, maybe it was diseased and needed to be removed, or maybe it was too big for the space. Regardless of why your tree needed to be removed, chances are this tree removal has created a sort of void in your landscaping, and you probably want to replace it. So, many homeowners ask; is it ok to plant a new tree in the same spot as the old tree after stump removal? Yes, it is definitely possible to plant a new tree in the same spot following stump removal, BUT there are many things to consider first and you’ll want to hire a professional to do the job!
Factors that can negatively affect your new tree when planted in the same spot:
- Previous Health Issues – What type of condition was the old tree in health wise? Was it infected with some sort of pest or disease that required removal? If this is the case, the type of tree you choose for your replant is extremely important. Picking a tree that won’t become infected by this particular pathogen is key to survival.
- Left Behind Roots – While stump removal methods like stump grinding will entirely remove the stump, it can be difficult to remove all of the remaining roots, especially if the tree was very large and very well established. If roots are left behind, they will decompose over time, but slowly, making it hard for your new tree to get the nutrients it needs to thrive. To avoid this, it is important to hire a professional tree service company that offers complete stump and root removal. Red Cedar grinds to a depth of 18 inches which allows for a new tree to be planted in the same spot immediately.
- The Sawdust – The sawdust that is created from stump grinding can change the soil’s nutrient balance. Soil with too much sawdust left behind will have a high carbon-to-nitrogen ration. Cleaning up well after stump removal is extremely important if your goal is to replant in this spot.
- Lack Of Nutrients – It’s possible that the old mature tree has stripped the soil of essential nutrients that young trees depend on for survival and growth. If this is the case, your Arborist will know the best plan of action to ensure that your new tree will survive.
Here are some things to consider/steps to take before planting a new tree in an old spot.
If you are replanting a tree in the same location as the last tree that was removed, dig out an area at least 3 times the size of the new tree’s root ball.- Fill the hole with good new dirt. It is best to mound the soil before planting due to settling.
- Consider choosing a much smaller tree than what was previously there so it has sufficient room to grow.
- Consider giving it time before planting a new tree so that if there are left behind roots, they have some time to decompose.
- Be sure to prepare the site. The site should feel as “new” as possible for your new young tree. Sawdust and as many roots as possible should be removed, and fresh topsoil should be added.
Replanting a new tree in the same spot as your old tree that was removed is very tricky and requires professional machinery, knowledge, and skills. If you are attempting DIY stump removal following your tree removal service, your chances of planting a new healthy tree in the same spot are much slimmer.
The most ideal situation for planting a new tree in this same exact spot is to hire a professional to grind the stump and plant your new tree. But, simply hiring a professional stump grinder is not always enough. Make sure that your Arborist knows that you want to replant in the same spot and that they are grinding to at least 18 inches to ensure that this is possible. If you need a tree removed and want a new tree planted in its place, contact Red Cedar for your free estimate, and let us make sure the job is done right allowing your new tree to thrive!